Chukwuma on December 28th, 2009

I found this image while reading “What Matters Now” by Seth Godin.

Seth Godin writes about marketing, the spread of ideas and managing both customers and employees with respect. “What Matters Now” is a collaborative effort by a number of social media and marketing experts. The e-book and the above image represent a fascinating perspective on marketing but I think it is an even more appropriate metaphor for how to view medical communication in the information age. I also recently had the opportunity to review an article in the British Medical Journal in which C.O. Hawthorne takes issue with a plea by another physician ( Dr. Hempson) to conform to accepted practices. In his correspondence to the journal, Dr. Hawthorne states:

The suggestion implied in these warnings (by Dr. Hempson) plainly is that somewhere within the province of medicine there exists a recognized and authoritative standard of ” orthodoxy ” – that is, a body of doctrine and practice presented by authority and received and adopted as true and valid on the word of authority, with, as a corollary, and for the contumacious, the penialty of exclusion from the ranks and communion of the faithful. Possibly there are professions to which these propositions apply. But most certainly they do not apply to the profession of medicine.

This was written in 1926; but I completely agree with Dr. Hawthorne as we enter 2010. Many of the discussions on this blog have detailed the dangers that can result when we in the medical field accept things “as they are” and do not question how we can improve them or make them work better for patients.

This is true for reform efforts, specific procedures live VBAC, communication technology and the participation of patients in their own care. Given the drastic changes in technology and the ability these provide us to radically change what we do for the best; we owe it to ourselves to question everything and seek to optimize patient care rather than do what we have done in the past.

Posted via web from onyeije’s posterous

Share This Post:
  • Print
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay

One Response to “What Matters Now: Avoiding Medical Orthodoxy”

  1. I could not agree more. I have always enjoyed questioning dogma, often to the chagrin of supervising physicians in my past. Such questioning is the only way to move forward, despite the short term pain it can cause.

    We are caught between two truisms:

    “Knowledge is not experience, and experience is not knowledge. Both are necessary for the ultimate goal of wisdom”

    and

    “Experience is what allows us to make the same mistakes with greater confidence”

    Both are true, but we have to be careful we are not in the wrong mindset on certain topics. Skepticism and a willingness to question dogma is a necessary part of that.

Leave a Reply